Epistemology

Human Ways of Forming Answers to Questions

TypeDescriptionA Principal UseStrengthWeakness
AuthoritarianismComposite of opinions of other human beingsTo know one’s mother tongueEasiestOften wrong
RationalismDeducing an answer from accepted premisesBalancing one’s checkbookVery sure if premises are correctPremises must be taken on faith
EmpiricismDirectly sensing something to know itFinding the exitHelps us to relate to our immediate environmentMany important things cannot be sensed
Statistical EmpiricismForming a conclusion on the basis of arrays of dataWhich ball bearing lasts longestVery good masses of empirical dataBiased sample gives wrong impressions
PragmatismCalling what works “the truth”When a baby cries, it is picked up and comfortedGreat last resortMay be coincidence
FabricationInventing a hypothesisDetective work Theory in science MathematicsHypothesis helps in recognizing evidenceWe may begin to believe our hypotheses, shutting off further thought
MysticismSubstituting “immediacy” for noetic knowingReligious satisfaction?Very satisfyingIntellectually empty
ScholarshipForming ideas about past on basis of authoritarianism, rationalism, and fabricationBiography of NapoleonGives a rational thread to accounts of the pastOften in error because of bias of extant documents
ScienceForming ideas about the universe on basis of authoritarianism, rationalism, statistical empiricism and fabricationCreation of the periodic tableHelps to discover and control natureCannot deal with the non-empirical
RevelationForming ideas on basis of communication with the supernaturalLearn the nature of GodMost productive means for the most important questions in lifeTwo sources, one good, one evil
Knowledge of Good and EvilFeelings of the heart which differentiate righteousness from selfishnessDifferentiate revelation from God from revelation from SatanPriceless key to all knowingVariable from person to person, because some are not honest in heart